본문으로 건너뛰기
NHLKey match

New York IslandersvsColumbus Blue Jackets

Scorebase model · match winner

New York Islanders 56%Columbus Blue Jackets 44%

Pick New York Islanders win 56%

Market-implied (vig removed)

New York Islanders 53% · Columbus Blue Jackets 40%

Handicap

Columbus Blue Jackets +1.5 71%

Match preview

Islanders vs Blue Jackets prediction: home form meets road collapse

Written 2026-11-17 · before kick-off · from the data above

New York Islanders are favoured at 56% to beat Columbus Blue Jackets in a matchup where the decisive factor is the visitors' alarming away record. Columbus have won just once in their last six road games, conceding 3.4 goals per game, whilst the Islanders have found form at home with back-to-back victories. The model picks the Islanders, but the AI panel shows meaningful disagreement on whether the margin will be comfortable or tight.

Where the model stands

The model assigns New York Islanders a 56% win probability against Columbus's 44%, placing them as clear home favourites. The Elo ratings support this view: Islanders sit at 1478 to Blue Jackets' 1451, a 27-point gap that translates to a modest but genuine edge. On the handicap line, Columbus +1.5 rates at 71% according to the model, suggesting the model expects a one-goal Islanders win as the modal outcome. The market-implied probability (bookmaker margin removed) shows Islanders at 52% and Blue Jackets at 40%, indicating the market is slightly less confident in the home side than the model.

Form and the table

The Islanders occupy 20th place with 27 points from 19 games, whilst Columbus sit 28th with 21 points from 18 games. New York's season record stands at 9–10, Columbus at 7–11, but the split between home and away performance is stark. At home, the Islanders are 4–5 with 1.33 points per game; away, Columbus have managed just 1–5 with 0.50 points per game. Over their last five matches, New York have scored 4.0 goals per game and conceded 3.4, whilst Columbus have scored only 1.8 and conceded 3.4. The Islanders have won their last two games and remain unbeaten in that stretch. Columbus, by contrast, have lost four of their last five, with their sole win coming in that sequence. Both teams have had three days' rest, so fatigue is not a differentiator.

Model vs market

The model's 56% for Islanders exceeds the market's 52%, a four-percentage-point gap suggesting the model views New York as slightly undervalued. On the handicap, the model backs Columbus +1.5 at 71%, implying confidence in a close game, whilst the market's equivalent probability is not explicitly stated. This divergence hints that the model may be pricing in the Islanders' home form and Columbus's road struggles more heavily than the market consensus.

What the AI panel thinks

The AI panel shows stronger conviction for an Islanders win than the model itself. Five of six independent models favour New York, with probabilities ranging from 51% to 69%—notably, Gemini 2.5 Flash reaches 69%, well above the model's 56%. On the handicap, opinion splits: Scorebase, Claude Fable and Grok favour Columbus +1.5, whilst Gemini and Kimi prefer Islanders -1.5. The panel is divided on total goals, with four models leaning Over 5.5 and two leaning Under, suggesting uncertainty about whether this will be a high-scoring affair or a tighter contest.

Verdict

The Islanders' home record (1.33 ppg) and recent form (two consecutive wins) provide a foundation for confidence, but Columbus's road collapse (0.50 ppg, 1–5) is the primary driver of the model's pick. The market is less convinced than the model, and the AI panel's split on the handicap reflects genuine uncertainty about whether New York will dominate or merely edge a competitive match. The Islanders are favoured, but this is not a mismatch.

Prediction: New York Islanders at 56%.

AI panel

What each model picked

Match winner

  • Scorebase ModelNew York Islanders 51%
  • GPT-5.6 SolNew York Islanders 66%
  • Claude Fable 5.1New York Islanders 62%
  • Grok 4.7New York Islanders 62%
  • Gemini 2.5 FlashNew York Islanders 69%
  • Kimi K3New York Islanders 64%

Handicap

  • Scorebase ModelColumbus Blue Jackets +1.5 71%
  • GPT-5.6 SolNew York Islanders -1.5 54%
  • Claude Fable 5.1Columbus Blue Jackets +1.5 56%
  • Grok 4.7Columbus Blue Jackets +1.5 54%
  • Gemini 2.5 FlashNew York Islanders -1.5 61%
  • Kimi K3New York Islanders -1.5 52%

Over / under

  • Scorebase ModelOver 5.5 60%
  • GPT-5.6 SolOver 5.5 59%
  • Claude Fable 5.1Under 5.5 54%
  • Grok 4.7Over 5.5 55%
  • Gemini 2.5 FlashOver 5.5 58%
  • Kimi K3Over 5.5 54%